Wonder Woman: Porn Star, Feminist Icon, Erotic Goddesss, or All of the Above?

This recent Playboy magazine cover has already been commented on all over the net with varying degrees of righteous scorn, insight, and “What’s the big deal/are you really so suprised-ness?” so while I doubt I have anything insightful to add I feel like should say something.
It’s distressing that the character who originated as a role model for girls (regardless of the problematic ideology of her creator) and was later adopted as a symbol of female empowerment has again been co-opted, not as a figure of women’s sexual empowerment, but as an image of male fantasy. (Then again, I suppose she has also always been this as well.)
But it’s almost like a sexist slap in the feminist face. Gloria Steinem was one of the champions of the Amazon Princess in the 1970s. In the 1960s she wrote her famous undercover expose of Playboy Clubs, “I Was a Playboy Bunny.” So in this we meet a moment of cultural irony.
I’ll bet the editors of Playboy thought they were merely being playful.* Wonder Woman is after all a recognizable symbol of a powerful woman.
I can’t say I’m happy about it, especially the comparison of this model/actress to Lynda Carter, but I can’t help but wonder what the response would be if this were a spread on Suicide Girls (Minimal pun intended).
*At least it’s not as insidious as the panel in the “Women’s Lib” issue of Wonder Woman where the writers actually had Diana say, “In most cases I don’t even like women . . .” Likely a childish message from the writers of Wonder Woman to the editors of Ms. for interfering with their work.
Labels: Wonder Woman


2 Comments:
Yeah-- there are a hella more jabs (like the one you mention) that would rile my feathers. Me, I don't mind positing WW as a male fantasy-- a male fantasy of a capable, powerful, & yes, sexual woman? I'm on board with that.
Well, it's possible for Wonder Woman to be both a male fantasy, and a female fantasy. That's what Marston intended. He wanted women to see that they could be independent, powerful, and sensuous, and men to see that they should honor this kind of woman.
Ms. furthered the idea of such a powerful role model and Wonder Woman has hence inspired other generations of girls & boys--at least mine. Lynda Carter's embodiment was enormously influential, and helped shape the woman I've become.
I have no problem with adopting a popular icon in a playful, sexual way. I have an Uhura mini-dress, and once even did a quick mock-up of Leia's ice planet outfit. But the difference between healthy play within a couple, and play on the pages of Playboy is that pornography perpetuates the assumption that women are objects. That they have no value. That they are for male pleasure only. That they are less than whole, or complex.
Regardless of Playboy's intentions, and the fact that as far as porn goes, they are relatively tame, the fact is the don't depict an empowered female sexuality. They show an object meant to titillate men. And this is the very problem that plagues superhero comics, and often, popular culture in general.
Fortunately, there are many people and organizations passionately, and eruditely speaking out about these issues. Ragnell, Greg Rucka, Girl Wonder,Joss Whedon, and so on understand the effect that images and storytelling can have on both the individual spirit and the cultural psyche. And I'm writing a book to champion the superwomen that have inspired.
Post a Comment
Links to this post:
Create a Link
<< Home